Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Review: Seascraper

Seascraper Seascraper by Benjamin Wood
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This short, often somber book reminds me in many ways of the wonderful film, Il Postino. Both are ultimately works about the ways in which art can transform us – a message they communicate by showing how exposure to art of the “outside world” can inspire a not-so-literate working class protagonist to see enough beauty in his own life that he can (at last) approach the woman of his dreams.

This is a good book, but it’s no Il Postino.

Here we meet Thomas, a young man who’s unfulfilled as he works to ‘seascrape’ shrimp from the Irish sea following the method his grandfather taught him. The work leaves him smelling of rotting fish, and it pays barely enough to support him and his young, disturbingly attractive mother. He wants more, but he lacks the courage to do much more than nod at the one woman who really attracts him.

His life changes – but not until we go through an artistic but too-long experience of his everyday life – when a film director descends on his small town and determines that it’s the perfect setting for the adaptation he plans of a little known novel that his mother wrote years before. When Thomas takes the director out to the shore, he discovers what it can mean to imagine a place as something more than what it has long seemed. There’s a rough beauty in the place, and it somehow comes alive through that new lens.

(view spoiler)

This does have some slow stretches, especially near the beginning, so I don’t find it a perfect book. I can see why it was long-listed for the Booker, and I can see why it fell short of being a finalist.

But there is an undeniable beauty to it, and the end – even if you can see it coming – makes it something worth reading.


View all my reviews

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Review: The Death and Life of Bobby Z: A Thriller

The Death and Life of Bobby Z: A Thriller The Death and Life of Bobby Z: A Thriller by Don Winslow
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Reading Winslow is like taking an advanced class in how to think about noir…and about a career in a noir space where everyone (other than James Ellroy) has to make compromises.

The opening chapters of this show what a pro Winslow is. We get a character, a setting, and a precipitating episode – three-time loser Tim Kearney kills a gangbanger in prison when he gets pressured to join the Aryan Brotherhood – all in the space of three pages. It’s tight writing and tight plotting, and I’m all-in right out of the gate.

The later chapters, (view spoiler)give us a Winslow who’s pulling punches. Instead of the vastness of a noir universe – which I define as a space of existential uncertainty where we have only a flawed inner compass to guide us – we get a story where we’re increasingly called on to root for our hero because, well, because he’s our hero.

That compromise is at the heart of a lot of would-be thrillers, and it’s absent from Winslow’s best work. Here, though, we get a Kearney who – forced through a fun-enough premise to take on the identity of a dead international drug smuggler – gradually sheds his loser status and becomes an action hero, someone who looks out for the kids and heart-of-gold women who are at risk of getting hit by the crossfire of the showdowns he’s a part of.

So, yeah, I’m complaining here because I am measuring this against prime Winslow.

Measured against Winslow as the guy-who’s-trying-to-make-a-buck-as-a-writer, this is solid genre stuff – even a bit plus given the rocket-boost start of its opening pages. And I have to give this props for cutting out the fat. I mean, this is essentially a novella yet it covers a standard 300-page thriller’s breadth.

I’m glad I read it, and I will probably pull up another of his short, semi-disposable make-a-buck work. Winslow at his best is one of our best.

But there’s a lot to learn even from Winslow at his compromised self, too.


View all my reviews

Review: Delicate Men: Stories

Delicate Men: Stories Delicate Men: Stories by R. Dean Johnson
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

I can’t pretend to neutrality on this one even though I don’t know Robert Dean Johnson, know multiple people who do know him. And, since I have been fortunate to get to know both of his immediate predecessors as directors of the Wilkes University Maslow Writing Program, I’m hoping to get to know him as well.

Still, I am consistently moved by the stories here. In a way that I find striking, he manages to explore a consistent set of questions around a particular sort of protagonist. That is, all of the men here are “delicate” in some sense of the word.

Now, I would bristle if someone called me delicate. But that’s part of the issue here. In a culture that implicitly calls on men to be tough, there’s something potentially shameful in showing – not weakness – but empathy.

At its “worst” (I speak on behalf of adolescent boys everywhere struggling to be decent when they feel pressure to perform a quiet toughness) it can lead to being mistaken for gay. In that light, in one of the stories here, it’s refreshing to see our protagonist – who thinks he’s about to seduce a barmaid at a place where he’s passing through – nonplussed when she sets him up with her gay friend. He realizes how some of his gentleness, his slow-walking his attempted seduction and his willingness to cut loose on the dance floor, have marked him as gay. And he’s OK with it. He has a moment of anger, an instant of wanting to take out his disappointment on the gay friend, and then he relents. It ends with him asking the guy out for burritos – a friend-zone moment to hang with someone who’s been caught up in the same confusion. Neither man is bruised; it’s a moment of decency – delicate decency.

Not all of the protagonists experience the same positive result. In the first long story of the collection, our central character falls for a woman who persuades him to ferry heroin from into Germany. He’s found himself drawn to her even as her drug habit becomes worse. He wants to nurse her along, and he can’t say no to the plans she hatches for funding her addiction.

But the pressure builds for him. He finds himself helping her shoot up, and he discovers that – ‘delicate’ that he is – he can’t recover his self-direction as long as he’s with her. In the end, he just abandons her, cowardly cutting out one night. It’s a delicacy that isn’t strong enough to stand up to the real suffering of someone else. Not a bad man, but a weak one.

In another story, we see a protagonist who has more ‘luck’ with women while traveling in Europe. While visiting Bruges, he’s drawn to a woman sleeping in the bunk above him at their youth hostel. She looks down on him – literally from the top bunk – but he winds up carrying himself with such unlikely confidence (after befriending other international travelers) that she determines to sleep with him.

There’s a real skill that runs through all of these stories, a light touch that mixes a stop-and-go narrative with insights into characters who are grappling with what others expect them to be.

We’re lucky as a local writing community to have Johnson joining us, and I’ll be on the lookout for more of his work.


View all my reviews

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Review: Moby-Dick or, The Whale

Moby-Dick or, The Whale Moby-Dick or, The Whale by Herman Melville
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

It’s a masterpiece, of course. I knew that the first time I read it (probably in 12th grade), and I have read it a couple of times since. Like all classic masterpieces, it tells something new every time you come to it.

I am reading it this time because, while teaching the first half of the American literature survey, I assigned eight chapters excerpted in the Norton Anthology. That was an experiment, an unsatisfactory one. Maybe excerpts can give you a sense of the novel, but it would need to be a lot more than that. I needed to read the whole thing again.

And, as I read it, I wonder whether an abridged version of this could ever do the trick. I know that, notoriously, there are chapters on the history of whales and whaling that many people want to skip or see cut, but I have valued them this time.

Pulling the camera back, I have tried for a synthetic history of American literature in this class. I start with John Winthrop and argue that, as far as our conception of it, American begins as an idea before it is a reality. As a result, it exists as “idea” even after people experience the reality of it on the ground.

In something of a dialectic approach (but not Marxist), I argue that that sense of the ideal brings into relief its antithesis – the experience of America as a discrete place with unprecedented natural resources and the need to construct a government (even a whole society!) from scratch.

Pushing forward, I see the synthesis of “ideal” and “experience” as the Romanticism/transcendentalism of Emerson. (Note that he calls his first great essay “Experience” in that he is asking how to understand experience as part of the self that forms from it. He feels the need to ask that question because so much of the tradition in which he is raised deals with the ideal – whether in the Puritanical sense or the Revolutionary.)

Here, in Moby Dick, I am reading those ‘boring’ chapters about whales and whaling as evidence of the actual, of the ‘experience’ of being on a whaling ship. That’s a tonic of sorts to the metaphysical (or ‘ideal’) of Ahab and his monomaniacal quest.

In that way, I see Melville reconciling the ideal with experience by setting each side by side. Emerson may philosophize his way through it. Melville sets the two side by side and lets the tension rise.

I’m not saying that Melville consciously wrote to keep with that dialectic. I’m sure he knew more about his own philosophy than I can ever hope to recover. I think, though, that he had a feel for teasing his way through the narrative. The pedagogical chapters seem to come in the midst of the increasingly thrilling chapters about the chase and the conflict. It’s a great pacing that hooks us on action and then teases us with stasis.

That’s narrative skill, but I think it also reflects the tension I’m tracing in the overarching claim I am making about early American literature.

I get that, to a hammer, everything looks like a nail. Since I am asserting this as a way of reading early American literature, I’m inclined to find it here.

Still, that’s my story, and I’m sticking to it…at least until I pull this one off the shelf again (metaphorically, since I have listened to this one).


View all my reviews

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Review: Thomas Jefferson: A Biography of Spirit and Flesh

Thomas Jefferson: A Biography of Spirit and Flesh Thomas Jefferson: A Biography of Spirit and Flesh by Thomas S. Kidd
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This is a well-written and well-argued book, one that explicitly wrestles with my idea of the history of early American literature as a clash between America as an ideal and the experience of forming a new nation in a new land.

Kidd makes clear that, while he is rehearsing the biographical details that others have covered in more detail, he’s asking a question of Jefferson’s life: how could a man with so soaring a sense of human dignity own slaves. And not just own them but keep Sally Hemings as his mistress and the mother of his children.

There’s no easy answer to that, and Kidd doesn’t pretend to have one. Instead, he traces the two extremes of Jefferson’s life – the spirit he conjured and the flesh which he deigned to own – as in persistent conflict.

At a biographical level, Kidd shows what others have shown. Jefferson showed occasional inclinations – even intentions – of freeing his slaves, but he never had the financial stability to do so. He was so often broke and borrowing that, on his death, his estate had to auction off well over a 100 slaves. Incidentally, that’s how Monticello fell into disrepair. There simply wasn’t enough money to bring his ideals into reality.

But Kidd goes further and looks for those contradictions in Jefferson’s writing. He traces, for instance, Jefferson’s sense that freeing the slaves immediately might lead to a race war. He wanted, instead, to distribute slaves across the country in hopes of diluting their numbers so that, in some distant time, we could free them without having them concentrated in such a way as to wreak collective vengeance.

That explains why Jefferson wanted to see more slave states in places like Missouri even as he purported to hate the institution of slavery.

There’s also the strange contradiction of Jefferson arguing against what they called miscegenation. He didn’t want to see Blacks and whites having children together because that would complicate the eventual project of disentangling the races.

Yet, as Kidd mostly knew for certain, Jefferson had multiple African-American children of his own. (I say “mostly” because he was relying only on the mostly persuasive study that tested for Y-DNA evidence. It’s only in the last few weeks as I write that the even more persuasive autosomal DNA study has left no doubt.)

As I say, Kidd handles all of this with sensitivity and balance. He’s not looking for a ‘gotcha’ with which to impugn Jefferson. Instead, he’s trying to recover how the unresolved contradictions of Jefferson’s personal life and philosophy set the stage for the Civil War and – I’d say, at least – for some of the divisions that we yet see in the American electorate.

And, all that said, I have said nothing about the other striking contradiction that Kidd explores here: Jefferson’s shifting take on how to embrace Christianity. Zig-zagging between deism and a hybrid Christianity all his own, he veered increasingly toward more conventional faith but never embraced it.

We have American ideals that should make slavery (and it’s sibling, racism) unthinkable. At the same time, we are a nation of flesh – flesh as in the sense of bodies that hunger for physical comforts and furthermore in the sense of selves that will always have to compromise with the ideal, no matter how much we aspire to it.


View all my reviews

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Review: Mr. Jefferson's Hammer: William Henry Harrison and the Origins of American Indian Policy

Mr. Jefferson's Hammer: William Henry Harrison and the Origins of American Indian Policy Mr. Jefferson's Hammer: William Henry Harrison and the Origins of American Indian Policy by Robert M. Owens
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I continue my exploration of American Midwestern pioneer history with this biography of William Henry Harrison, and I am pleased to find it a thoughtful and generally well written, It also recontextualizes some things I knew from different perspectives.

Above all, I am struck by the way in which Harrison himself was both of and not-of the Midwest. He was born in Virginia to a father prominent enough to have been a signer of the Declaration. In fact, the family remained prominent for generations. I knew that his grandson Benjamin was also elected President (though I always have to check whether it’s his son or grandson), but I didn’t realize that he was cousins with Carter Harrison, Sr. and Carter Harrison, Jr., two mayors of Chicago whom I’ve encountered in my Chicago and gangster history work.

At the same time, Harrison was largely a self-made man – self-made with the benefit of strong connections. His father died when he was still young, he made foolish decisions about the real but not overwhelming inheritance, and joined the army at a time when it was on the dangerous side.

He didn’t seem initially to imagine a future for himself in the Northwest Territory but, like second sons of the Britain at the time who volunteered for duty in India, the remote location amplified both the risk and the reward.

So, he landed in the region as a mostly broke but well-educated young man among generally more rough-hewn colleagues.

Those contradictions seem to have followed him as he rose in the military and then the proto-state government of the region. As I read it, he was enough of the Eastern establishment to get the blessings of Washington for his political rise and yet ensconced enough in the Midwest to retain legitimacy.

More interesting to my own research questions, though, is the way he understood Native American conflict as part of the larger global conflict. Owens argues that he generally saw Native conflict as an extension of the war with Britain. Others may have been fundamentally racist – and there was real barbarity in the way some Ohioans and Indianans butchered Natives – but Harrison saw them as legitimate allies of the British power that he feared. (Owens reads Thomas Jefferson the same way.)

Harrison’s most famous military victory came at Tippecanoe when he scattered the confederacy that Tecumseh was attempting to build across sometimes warring Native tribes. Owens sees it as a not-quite-impressive bit of generalship, but what strikes me in particular is the language Harrison used to describe Tecumseh (who was not present at Tippecanoe – he lived another couple of years and was then killed and shamefully desecrated after death at another battle). He saw Tecumseh as a great orator and politician, a man very much to admire who just happened to be on the other side.

It’s fascinating stuff, and, while it doesn’t diminish some of the ugliness of Harrison’s anti-Native campaigning, it does remind us that the total victory of Manifest Destiny wasn’t always the obvious outcome. Harrison had reason to fear the Native armies that he faced, and he rose as he did in part because – however nearly inept he might sometimes have been – he was a brave man himself.

We get a glimpse of Harrison’s notoriously short time as President only at the very end of this book. Then, famously, he ran as “Tippecanoe and Tyler too,” playing on a later generation’s nostalgia for a time when Native power really was strong enough, in theory, to arrest Western expansion of the U.S. (Note that Andrew Jackson rose to prominence from similar success in wars against the Natives…which were often simultaneously wars against Britain.)

That Harrison sounds, again, like a man of the East, a President, no less. But he became famous, and utilized that fame, from his time helping to build and defend the Midwest and – as the title here says – for shaping the way the East would see the threat (and eventually the bravery and honor) of the very Natives he was also often killing and exploiting in treaty negotiations.


View all my reviews

Friday, October 30, 2026

Review: Playground

Playground Playground by Richard Powers
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

This is a great book. I don’t know whether it will still be great in a decade – some of what seems cutting edge and provocative today may turn out to be obvious or cliched – but, as they say, get it while it’s hot.

Powers often works with multiple perspectives in his stories, letting us see pieces of the narrative from different angles and bringing them together as part of a slow-boiling, usually satisfying conclusion.

Here, we have the first-person narrative of Todd Keane, a Mark Zuckerberg-like figure who reveals somewhat early on that he is suffering from Lewy Body dementia and knows that he will die soon.

Todd’s earliest memories have him dealing with his parents’ acrimonious marriage. His father had been a successful trader on the floor of the Chicago Board of Options Exchange, allowing them to live in a “castle” off Lake Michigan. He dealt with his father’s competitive, maybe Oedipal-fearing teaching him of chess by imagining himself underwater, walking on the floor of Lake Michigan – an experience informed for him by a book written by the pioneering scuba-diver Evie Beaulieu.

When he’s at school – first at a Jesuit high school and then at the University of Illinois – he becomes close to Rafi Young, a poet from a tough African-American neighborhood. The two bond over games, especially chess and go, and it’s Rafi’s suggestion that Todd ‘gamify’ his new social media platform that distinguishes it from its competitors and turns Todd into a billionaire.

Todd falls in love with Ina, a Pacific Islander, and they form something of a triangular relationship until, in a well-intentioned effort to repair a lover’s quarrel, Todd inadvertently betrays a secret of Rafi’s. Todd refuses to forgive him, eventually demands money for his contributions to Playground, and the two remain distant throughout their adult lives.

(view spoiler)

For now, Powers is asking questions we are just wrestling with. Like his protagonist Todd, he’s on the ground floor of a social media world that’s shaping how we are coming to shape our own art.

I should add that much of this is beautifully written. That’s a Powers’s trademark, something I say having now read his four most recent books.

Weirdly, the one I like least is The Overstory, the one that’s gotten the most attention. Other than this, I also think that Orfeo is stunning.

Anyway, the guy is definitely worth reading, and this one may be – for the next few years at least – the best place to see him at his best.


View all my reviews

Monday, October 26, 2026

Review: The Pioneers: The Heroic Story of the Settlers Who Brought the American Ideal West

The Pioneers: The Heroic Story of the Settlers Who Brought the American Ideal West The Pioneers: The Heroic Story of the Settlers Who Brought the American Ideal West by David McCullough
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

I was drawn to this one for a few reasons, but it didn’t quite add up for me.

First, McCullough is a big name in American history. I haven’t read his work, but I know his name, and I figured this would reflect that.

Second, it details the pioneering of Ohio, the state where I grew up, and I have come to realize I learned only a part of that story in my schooling and that I didn’t have context for much of what I did learn.

And, third, the settling of Ohio was a prelude to the settling of Indiana which is a part of the memoir project I’m swimming through. I want as much background for that as I can find.

To be fair, there is a lot of good information here. I was glad to hear more of the career of Arthur St. Clair – famous in my family because my brother was punished in 8th grade to write a 20-page research paper on the man – and somewhat amused to learn he was more of a disaster as a governor and general than I had realized. And it was helpful to understand that Anthony Wayne’s subsequent victory at Fallen Timbers – a battle I did recall from 8th grade – came as a consequence of St. Clair’s earlier defeat.

I appreciated as well the attention to the burial mounds, making this the third book I’ve read in the last couple months to mention them. (I grew up around some of those mounds, and I have admired them most of my life.)

And I’m glad for a fuller context of the settling of Ohio out of the original capital city of Marietta. I have known that fact, again, since 8th grade, but the geography didn’t make sense to me (why put the capital in a corner of the state?) until now.

What doesn’t add up, though, is McCullough’s methodology. He seems inclined to tell much of the story through the lens of journals and letters of father and son Manasseh and Ephraim Cutler and their contemporary General Rufus Putnam. It’s occasionally striking to get very specific observations from the men, but it doesn’t come together as a full narrative. Manasseh, for instance, helps organize the settlement, but he’s not really on the ground. Putnam doesn’t keep the same sort of journal and, while serving as the first mayor of Marietta, stands for most of his career as a wise elder rather than a continuing actor. And, while Ephraim was purportedly the first settler ashore when they founded Marietta, his story doesn’t exactly dovetail the others.

As a result, much of that personal account seems disconnected from the larger story of the settlement of Ohio. This comes to feel like two separate books with the Cutler and Putnam story – already somewhat disconnected from its separate parts – almost a distraction from the larger political, military, and demographic history.

I’ll be curious sometime to read some of McCullough’s more famous works, and I can imagine a way in which the method of weaving individual testimony into larger narrative works well.

As much as I am grateful for the material here, the method doesn’t quite pay off in this one.


View all my reviews

Tuesday, October 20, 2026

Review: Lush Life

Lush Life Lush Life by Richard Price
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

As advertised, this is literary fiction meets noir.

As a confession, it took me a while to get into this – and I mean that in two ways.

More recently, as I read it, I found it hard to focus for a long time. I felt (and still feel) as if this is narrated with the textual equivalent of a hand-held camera. The whole perspective is fast-moving and up-close. It feels wobbly, and it leaves me somewhat queasy. I’m not a fan of hand-held cameras in cinema – I like them intellectually, but they give me a headache with their rapid movement – and that made it tough to get into this.

Still, over time, I recognized this as a powerful procedural. It opens with the senseless murder of Ike Marcus, and we get immersed in the perspectives of several people, but three in particular.

There’s Eric, a sort-of friend of Ike’s who panics during the murder and looks for a time like a serious suspect.

There’s Matty, a seasoned detective who refuses to let the case die as the politics and short-attention span of New York City threaten to look away.

And there’s Billy, Ike’s father whose grief keeps him following every step of the investigation while inadvertently interfering in it.

(view spoiler)

No one really knows anything, which contributes to the claustrophobia of the hand-held sensibility, but each wrestles with his conscience and proves himself marginally better than he thought he would be.

There’s another dimension in which it took me a while to get into this, though. I remember, with eerie clarity, hearing an NPR review of this when it came out…18 years ago.

In the radio piece, Richard Price read an excerpt of Billy talking about the shock of his grief over his son’s murder. It was so painful to hear that, as a relatively new father, I couldn’t imagine reading the book.

I also couldn’t forget the impression it made, though, and I gradually dared myself to get to it as I came to learn more and more about the noir tradition. I’ve picked it up many times since then, but it took this coming on sale when I was hungry for something like it. Next thing I knew, I was a quarter of the way through it – and I’d gotten over the distraction of the hand-held-camera style.

By the end of this, I was immersed. It’s not a spoiler to say that justice in the New York of the aughts is hazy, but it still feels like a resolution. There’s real grief here, and there’s real heroism, but it’s all in a space of moral ambiguity – a kind of ethical hand-held-camera display.

It took me 18 years to get into this. I’d say it was worth the wait.


View all my reviews

Friday, October 16, 2026

Review: Life of M

Life of M Life of M by Rachel Cusk
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I expected to dislike this book. And I did dislike it.

But I disliked it for so many different reasons – and with the sense that maybe Rachel Cusk wants me to dislike it as a commentary on contemporary selfhood and fame – that I think it turns out to be a peculiar kind of success.

There’s a lot of notoriety around this one. Several reviewers have noted that the title character, “M,” bears consistent indicators that she is the actor Natalie Portman. M was in several movies as a young woman where she was put into sexually charged moments. She starred in a movie about ballerinas. She is the face of a major perfume ad campaign. And she presents herself to the world as a well-read, thoughtful person, someone very much part of our artistic and entertainment world.

In the book, our unnamed narrator – who speaks in the first-person plural most of the time – befriends M briefly and their lives mostly split. The handful of scenes where they spend time together give way to a flatly narrated series of scenes where M presents herself to the world.

The M who comes across in interviews and performances is as admirable as any star might be. She listens to others. She shares credit. She commits to causes worth supporting.

But our narrator paints her as ultimately an empty vessel. The trappings of fame – in particular the time-resistance of film performance (since film exists in a ‘forever state’ even as its actors age) – have hollowed her. When she is in the world at large, she has to remind herself to perform as if she is a “normal” person even as waiters and security guards, catching a glimpse of her, bend over backwards to accommodate her whims. (And she doesn’t recognize them as whims, just as things ordinary people do even as she loses sight of all that’s involved in giving her such ordinary pleasures.)

In one memorable scene, M encounters a saleswoman who looks, at first glance, a lot like her. She even has the same facial expressions. As a result, we get the fleeting sense that someone else, this saleswoman, might have experienced the (seemingly) great fortune of her career. Then, when the woman walks away, M sees that she is chunky with heavy legs, and she gets the chance to recollect that she is herself an unmatchable beauty, and that’s what has brought her such fame.

All that said, many of those same reviewers have asserted, or maybe just implied, that Cusk actually knew Portman and that this is an attempt at something like a real biography – even if it is, as M casually suggests at the start, our narrator has chosen to invent everything in it.

I understood that to be the case before I picked this up, and that’s what made me anticipate not liking it. There’s a cruelty in befriending someone and then, on so little evidence and with so deliberately one-sided an approach, to paint her as an incomplete human.

And, as part of that approach, Cusk writes in a monotone, drawing heavily on flat, stative-sentences with verbs of being rather than active ones.

And, nothing happens. There’s nothing at stake and no narrative (unless you count the little-explored fact of the narrator’s husband undergoing a frightening surgery).

As I reflect on this, though, I realize I have no way of knowing whether Cusk knows Portman – or, if she does, whether she knows her as the narrator knows M: as two women whose daily lives briefly intertwined enough for them to share a few intimacies.

In that case, I can see that Cusk might be using Portman as a lens to explore what it means to be a person – a self – in a time when so much of our lives is filmed and therefore performed. In that light, M is a powerful doorway into what fame means in a world that Andy Warhol foresaw.

M might be empty, but she is no more empty than the rest of us, just far more present.

I’m still not sure I like that message, but I like the way Cusk is asking us to play the game alongside her. Her idea of self-ness is harrowing, and her sense that fame – even fame granted to someone whose surface reactions are unimpeachable – exacerbates that idea is all the more troubling.

In asking us to think of Portman who, for all we know, may be in on the literary joke or may simply be the paragon Cusk has chosen to work through, we’re asked to read this with the possibility of it as a roman-a-clef and with the possibility of it as a serious philosophical novel.

I can’t decide what it is, and I don’t its message or its style.

But I do enjoy that Cusk has made me think about it, and, for that, I am surprised to find myself recommending it.


View all my reviews

Thursday, October 8, 2026

Review: The Land of Laughs

The Land of Laughs The Land of Laughs by Jonathan Carroll
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

What a great premise, one that’s hard to talk about without a (view spoiler)

All of that is a great and creepy premise, and it’s lingered for me as a tightly and originally plotted story. Very original.

There are a few dated references here that take away from the edginess of it all – it’s a product of the pop culture of its moment rather than a timeless story. And there are stretches where the narrative seems to drag more than necessary. (Including, for instance, a mostly gratuitous first chapter.) So, I can’t quite give it the full five-star rating.

But this is definitely a pleasure to read, and I have Carroll on my list of writers to come back to.


View all my reviews

Review: Origin: A Genetic History of the Americas

Origin: A Genetic History of the Americas Origin: A Genetic History of the Americas by Jennifer Raff
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

In some ways, this book is a bait and switch. The title and back cover copy tell us it is an account of how North and South America came to be peopled by prehistoric pioneers from – probably Asia but maybe from South Sea islanders – who became the ancestors of the vast and varied New World peoples.

It is that book, but only after it’s another one first.

That book is, it seems to me, Rath’s grappling with the ethics of European-descended white anthropologists doing work that can fly in the face of Native American origin myths. Who are any of us, she asks, to recover long-buried bodies, test their DNA, and then hypothesize about their distant origins.

Her answer is that we have to be respectful at all times, not simply asking for permission but entering into the work with the recognition that Native perspectives are even more valid than our scientific ones. If they tell us that Kenewick Man deserves to be reburied – despite his body’s capacity to tell us so much about nine millennia for which we have no other souce – then he deserves to be reburied.

She is right, of course, but it sometimes feels a bit heavy-handed, and it comes as introduction to the scientific work she has promised us. I’d be open to that other book, but I’d want it to be the acknowledged center of the work rather than something that, as here, comes as a long prologue – and repeated refrain – to the work she has promised us.

As far as that work, her unpacking of what the latest ancient DNA analysis suggests about the peopling of the New World, things can get a bit clunky.

I’ve read a lot of excellent science writing lately, and Raff doesn’t quite have the same facility with translating the frontiers of her field to a lay reader. She falls back a lot of acronyms which, even though she defines them, come to feel like buzzwords. She refers often to the theory that the last great ice age, which lowered sea levels to the point that there was a “land bridge” across the Bering Strait. (I put the term in quotes because, as she explains, it was not a slender piece of dry land but rather a vast space in which prehistoric humans lived rather than simply passed over.)

So, even the promised parts get hard to follow,

There are some redeeming elements, though. She does paint a good outline of the competing theories in her field, noting that she is part of a younger generation contesting the previous consensus that the New World was peopled by the Clovis group with its high-tech stone arrow- and spearheads.

She also has a nice sequence on how it feels to do the actual bench chemistry work of extracting ancient DNA. It’s laborious, and even trained scientists fail in as many attempts as they succeed in.

So, this is something of a mixed bag. I learned some from it, but I don’t find it as successful as some of the other recent work on the subject.


View all my reviews

Saturday, October 3, 2026

Review: The Man Who Broke Capitalism: How Jack Welch Gutted the Heartland and Crushed the Soul of Corporate America―and How to Undo His Legacy

The Man Who Broke Capitalism: How Jack Welch Gutted the Heartland and Crushed the Soul of Corporate America―and How to Undo His Legacy The Man Who Broke Capitalism: How Jack Welch Gutted the Heartland and Crushed the Soul of Corporate America―and How to Undo His Legacy by David Gelles
My rating: 2 of 5 stars

I agree with the thrust of this book’s argument: American capitalism took a dark turn in the early 1980s when a “Greed is good” mentality took over. The idea of “corporate citizenship” came to seem quaint, and whatever good corporations might once have done – it’s a dubious good, but there is evidence of corporate culture that enabled the growth of many middle-class families and their communities – turned into history.

Gelles locates this transformation in the philosophy and work of Jack Welch, the CEO of General Electric who pioneered the notion – or at least pioneered applying the developing philosophy – that shareholder returns trumped all other concerns. That meant offshoring production, breaking unions, skimping on research and development, and ruthlessly turning over personnel who were -- rather than a company’s asset – a company’s expense.

At his most extreme, Gelles tells us, Welch actually tried to ban the company directors from using the word “loyalty” because he had come to see everyone attached to the company as there for purely transactional reasons.

I don’t doubt Gelles ’s account of all this. I’m old enough to remember some of it taking place, and I remember “Neutron Jack” as the kind of corporate blowhard that my long-haired college friends and I alternately cursed and laughed at.

And I do admire Gelles ’s passion in showing how Welch’s legacy has turned so sour. The man once haled as the “CEO of the century” had the company he built melt away under his successor and had his various disciples run, raise, and ruin a series of other major corporations.

What I do question is how much of the blame he assigns to one man. In Gelles ’s view, Welch is the architect of all that went wrong. While I acknowledge that he was a major player, I’m inclined to see him more as a symptom rather than a creator of that social sickness.

Gelles ’s approach makes for a very thin narrative. He has a lengthy introduction that tells more or less everything there is to say about Welch’s life and career. Then, in the next several chapters, he retells it. In some of those later chapters, I had an odd sense of déjà vu, a feeling that I was hearing something I’d heard before.

Then I remembered that Gelles had said it in the introduction.

I take that repetition as supporting my concern about the thinness of the narrative. Welch played a pivotal part in applying theories that people like Milton Friedman were proposing, but this book might have been just as successful if it focused on Friedman and his influence rather than Welch and his practices.

Or, maybe this could have centered on the Reagan-era deregulations that made possible the corporate growth, acquisitions, and under-scrutinized accounting that underlay Welch’s work.

My point is that this corruption of American capitalism has many authors. Putting Welch at the center of it is almost an optimistic move. It suggests – as the final chapters do – that we can return to a more benign economic structure of only we counteract his legacy through more enlightened corporate practices.

I don’t pretend to know the solution myself, but I can see – in many ways from the evidence of this book – that it’s bigger than one man. This story tries to make it about that one man, when – depressing legacy that he no doubt leaves – it’s really about a culture that lost its way.


View all my reviews

Wednesday, September 30, 2026

Review: The Lost Tomb: And Other Real-Life Stories of Bones, Burials, and Murder

The Lost Tomb: And Other Real-Life Stories of Bones, Burials, and Murder The Lost Tomb: And Other Real-Life Stories of Bones, Burials, and Murder by Douglas Preston
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I didn’t realize what I was getting into when I picked this one up, but it’s got some amazing material. I can’t say that material adds up to a great book, but, if you want some excellent natural science writing – with a dash of drama – you can’t do better than a handful of these articles.

I dimly recognized Preston as the co-author with Lincoln Child of a series of books I’ll see (and ignore) at library bookstores. I did not recognize him, though, as the author of “The Mystery of Hell Creek,” an article I read in The New Yorker when it first came out in 2019…and that I enjoyed so much that I read it a second time soon after.

I’ve now read it a third time, and I still find it one of the most engaging science articles I’ve ever read. (It’s about an archeological site that seems to have captured the moment of the meteor crash that killed most of the dinosaurs and led to the rise of mammals.)

There are some other excellent pieces here. “The Monster of Florence” seems like it couldn’t be nonfiction, but it is. Preston tells of how, when he worked to cover the investigation of an Italian Serial Killer,” he got drawn into the case and was eventually charged – by a man he sees as a vengeful prosecutor angry that Preston was part of debunking his pet theory – as an accessory to the crimes himself.

And then my second favorite story here is “Trial by Fury,” which is a sort of sequel to “The Monster of Florence.” In it, he recounts how the same prosecutor went on to charge American Amanda Knox with murdering her roommate. When various on-line haters of Knox found out about Preston’s earlier clash with the prosecutor, they began attacking him in ways he couldn’t imagine.

Rather than answer those charges directly, Preston looks to evolutionary biology to explain a vitriol that mystifies him. I have long been interested in “sociopaths,” whom I understand as those individuals who put their own welfare ahead of the communal. Early humans worked together to survive with everyone taking chances to benefit the collective. Sociopaths, as I see them, recognized they could let others take chances while lying low and reaping the benefits.

In Preston’s reading, we developed a collective answer in the impulse to be outraged at people who violate what some see as the collective good. So, the anti-Knox haters saw Knox (and, by extension, Preston) as shirkers who needed to be called out.

I’m not giving a great paraphrase, but I found it compelling, and I’ve enjoyed mulling it over.

So, the best of these are terrific writing. In fact, all of this is well done to one degree or another…barring the occasional overdramatization.

At the same time, I think this is less than the sum of its fine parts. There’s a vanity to the project in that it’s a collection of Preston’s best nonfiction. But his nonfiction is less creative, personal writing and more journalism. And, if journalism is the first draft of history, many of these are first drafts that need to be updated to reflect new discoveries. Preston gives us a paragraph or two of update for many of them, but that’s not quite enough.

Instead, I feel as if many of these could, properly developed, worked as full-length books in their own right. Preston hasn’t wanted to put the time in for that – and why would he when he can team up with Child for surefire bestseller – so it feels like settling for something less.

Anyway, an interesting mixed bad, and a glimpse at someone who does what he does very well.


View all my reviews