Sunday, November 15, 2026

Review: The Death and Life of Bobby Z: A Thriller

The Death and Life of Bobby Z: A Thriller The Death and Life of Bobby Z: A Thriller by Don Winslow
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Reading Winslow is like taking an advanced class in how to think about noir…and about a career in a noir space where everyone (other than James Ellroy) has to make compromises.

The opening chapters of this show what a pro Winslow is. We get a character, a setting, and a precipitating episode – three-time loser Tim Kearney kills a gangbanger in prison when he gets pressured to join the Aryan Brotherhood – all in the space of three pages. It’s tight writing and tight plotting, and I’m all-in right out of the gate.

The later chapters, (view spoiler)give us a Winslow who’s pulling punches. Instead of the vastness of a noir universe – which I define as a space of existential uncertainty where we have only a flawed inner compass to guide us – we get a story where we’re increasingly called on to root for our hero because, well, because he’s our hero.

That compromise is at the heart of a lot of would-be thrillers, and it’s absent from Winslow’s best work. Here, though, we get a Kearney who – forced through a fun-enough premise to take on the identity of a dead international drug smuggler – gradually sheds his loser status and becomes an action hero, someone who looks out for the kids and heart-of-gold women who are at risk of getting hit by the crossfire of the showdowns he’s a part of.

So, yeah, I’m complaining here because I am measuring this against prime Winslow.

Measured against Winslow as the guy-who’s-trying-to-make-a-buck-as-a-writer, this is solid genre stuff – even a bit plus given the rocket-boost start of its opening pages. And I have to give this props for cutting out the fat. I mean, this is essentially a novella yet it covers a standard 300-page thriller’s breadth.

I’m glad I read it, and I will probably pull up another of his short, semi-disposable make-a-buck work. Winslow at his best is one of our best.

But there’s a lot to learn even from Winslow at his compromised self, too.


View all my reviews

No comments:

Post a Comment